An ongoing research project with
Coordinated disinformation campaigns are more likely to thrive when they go unnoticed and unchecked. This interactive visualizer breaks down the methods, targets, and origins of select coordinated disinformation campaigns throughout the world.
This project visualizes coordinated disinformation campaigns identified by the Atlantic Council’s DFRLab. Alphabet does not endorse these research findings or their characterization of disinformation campaigns.
An ongoing research project with
Twitter's Hong Kong Archives: Chinese Commercial Bots at Work.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetHong Kong
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsInfluential Individual, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Catalonia Twitter Takedown: Inorganic Campaign Pushed Pro-Independence Content.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetSpain
-
MethodsBrigading, Sockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Non-State Political Actor, Influential Individual
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Royally Removed: Facebook Takes Down Pages Promoting Saudi Interests.
-
Date first seen2017
-
TargetTurkey
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media, Advertisment
Bot-Like Accounts and Pro-Government Hashtags in Colombia.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetColombia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsMilitary, Influential Individual
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Gavrilov’s Night': Multiple Facebook Pages Target Protests in Georgia.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetGeorgia
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Influential Individual, Minority/Majority Group
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Facebook Takes Down the 'Voice of Truth' in Ukraine.
-
Date first seen2012
-
TargetUkraine
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook Takes Down Inauthentic Pages with Connections to Thailand.
-
Date first seen2010
-
TargetThailand
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Libyan Hashtag Campaign Has Broader Designs: Trolling Qatar.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetLibya
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsMilitary, Political Party, Terrorism
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Facebook Removes Iran-based Assets. Again.
-
Date first seen2015
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections, Non-State Political Actor
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Facebook Dismantled Iranian Influence Operation.
-
Date first seen2015
-
TargetWest and Central Africa
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Political Party, Minority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#ElectionWatch: Bots on Both Sides in India.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetIndia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsSocial Media
IN DEPTH: Iranian Propaganda Network Goes Down.
-
Date first seen2016
-
TargetIndonesia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsInfluential Individual, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#TrollTracker: Venezuelan Government-linked Influence Campaign on Twitter.
-
Date first seen2014
-
TargetVenezuela
-
MethodsBrigading, Botnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#TrollTracker: Facebook Takes Down Fake Network in the United Kingdom.
-
Date first seen—
-
TargetUnited Kingdom
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsInfluential Individual, Minority/Majority Group, Terrorism
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#TrollTracker: Facebook Takes Down Fake Network in Romania.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetRomania
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#TrollTracker: Spam Attack on Secretary Pompeo.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsOther
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#ElectionWatch: Insta-Deception Targets Ukraine.
-
Date first seen—
-
TargetUkraine
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Political Party, Elections
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#InfluenceForSale: Venezuela’s Twitter Propaganda Mill.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetVenezuela
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsSocial Media, Messaging Platforms
#TrollTracker: Outward Influence Operation From Iran.
-
Date first seen2010
-
TargetMiddle East
-
MethodsSockpuppets, Other Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor, Influential Individual, Minority/Majority Group, Terrorism, Immigration, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#ElectionWatch: Likes from Afar in Oaxaca.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMexico
-
MethodsOther
-
Topics—
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Facebook’s Sputnik Takedown — In Depth.
-
Date first seen2010
-
TargetBaltic States
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#ElectionWatch: Italy’s Self-Made Bots.
-
Date first seen2014
-
TargetItaly
-
MethodsBrigading, Botnets, Other
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Russia’s Full Spectrum Propaganda.
-
Date first seen2017
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsBrigading, Sockpuppets, Botnets
-
TopicsInfluential Individual
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#TrollTracker: Glimpse Into a French Operation.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetFrance
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Minority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#BalticBrief: NATO Not Planning To Invade Belarus.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetLithuania
-
MethodsSockpuppets, Data Exfiltration
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor
-
PlatformsOpen Web
#TrollTracker: Facebook’s Midterm Takedown.
-
Date first seen—
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Influential Individual, Minority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#ElectionWatch: FGV DAPP Uncovers Foreign Twitter Influence in Brazil.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetBrazil
-
MethodsSockpuppets, Botnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#TrollTracker: Facebook Uncovers Iranian Influence Operation.
-
Date first seen—
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Political Party, Non-State Political Actor, Minority/Majority Group, Terrorism
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#PutinAtWar: WADA Hack Shows Kremlin Full-Spectrum Approach.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsDDoS, Data Exfiltration
-
TopicsNon-State Political Actor, Influential Individual, Immigration, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#ElectionWatch: Protests Reinterpreted Online in Brazil.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetBrazil
-
MethodsBrigading, Data Exfiltration, Other Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#ElectionWatch: Inauthentic Activity Tested Ahead Naming Referendum.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetNorth Macedonia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#TrollTracker: Iran’s Suspected Information Operation.
-
Date first seen—
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Political Party, Non-State Political Actor, Minority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#ElectionWatch: Post-Electoral Bots in Puebla.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMexico
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#TrollTracker: Russian Traces in Facebook Takedown
-
Date first seen2017
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Non-State Political Actor, Minority/Majority Group
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#BotSpot: Bots Join Backlash Against Islamophobic Cartoon Contest.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetNetherlands
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#BalticBrief: False Story About Collapsed Mall Doesn’t Hold Up.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetLatvia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsOther
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#ElectionWatch: Italy’s Far Right Attacks Right in Closing Moments.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetItaly
-
MethodsBrigading, Botnets, Other Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Non-State Political Actor
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#BalticBrief: False Claim of Plans for Ethnic Cleansing in Latvia.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetLatvia
-
Methods—
-
TopicsMilitary, Minority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Bot Battlefield at #AMLOFest.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMexico
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections, Immigration
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#BalticBrief: Disinformation Through Mistranslation.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetLithuania
-
MethodsOther Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
TopicsMilitary
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Inauthentic Sputnik-Linked Pages Target the Armenian Diaspora.
-
Date first seen—
-
TargetArmenia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Influential Individual, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook Disabled Assets Linked to Egypt and UAE-Based Firms.
-
Date first seen2015
-
TargetMiddle East
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Elections, Terrorism, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
How a “Political Astroturfing” App Coordinates Pro-Israel Influence Operations.
-
Date first seen2019
-
Target—
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor, Terrorism
-
PlatformsSocial Media
From Telegram to Twitter: Top Puerto Rican Officials Plotted Possible Information Operation.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetPuerto Rico
-
MethodsBrigading, Sockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Armenia Assailed by Deceptive “Fact-Checking” Groups, Part 1: The Players.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetArmenia
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsOther
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Social Media Spam Tactics in Indonesia.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetIndonesia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Inauthentic Israeli Facebook Assets Target the World.
-
Date first seen2017
-
TargetWest Africa
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#ElectionWatch: Facebook Takes Down Network Supporting Indonesian Presidential Candidate Prabowo Subianto.
-
Date first seen—
-
TargetIndonesia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsElections, Minority/Majority Group
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Civilian Militias in Venezuela Coordinate on Twitter.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetVenezuela
-
MethodsBrigading, Botnets
-
TopicsMilitary
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#BotSpot: Bots Target Malaysian Elections.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMalaysia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Facebook Takes down Iranian Assets, Some Targeting Latin American Audiences.
-
Date first seen2016
-
TargetLatin America
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor, Terrorism, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Sockpuppet Accounts Impersonate India’s Space Agency Chief.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetIndia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Secondary Infektion Redux? Suspected Russian Intelligence Operation Targets Greenland.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetGreenland
-
MethodsOther Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
Topics—
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook and Twitter Remove Accounts Connected to Spanish Political Party.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetSpain
-
MethodsBrigading, Sockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media, Messaging Platforms
Coordinated Comments in Macedonia
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMacedonia
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Bot-like Turkish Accounts Complement Military Operation in Syria.
-
Date first seen2019
-
Target—
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor, Minority/Majority Group, Terrorism, Immigration
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Facebook Removes Assets Connected to Egyptian Newspaper El Fagr.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetEgypt
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
UAE Facebook Pages Targeted Qatar and Muslim Brotherhood.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMiddle East and North Africa (MENA)
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Non-State Political Actor, Terrorism
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook Takes down Pro-Indonesian Pages Targeting West Papua.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetIndonesia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group, Terrorism, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Inauthentic Pages Linked to Majority Government Taken down in Georgia.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetGeorgia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
5
10
15
20
25
Number of events
Facebook Takes Down Inauthentic Pages with Connections to Thailand.
-
Date first seen2010
-
TargetThailand
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#TrollTracker: Outward Influence Operation From Iran.
-
Date first seen2010
-
TargetMiddle East
-
MethodsSockpuppets, Other Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor, Influential Individual, Minority/Majority Group, Terrorism, Immigration, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook’s Sputnik Takedown — In Depth.
-
Date first seen2010
-
TargetBaltic States
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook Takes Down the 'Voice of Truth' in Ukraine.
-
Date first seen2012
-
TargetUkraine
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#TrollTracker: Venezuelan Government-linked Influence Campaign on Twitter.
-
Date first seen2014
-
TargetVenezuela
-
MethodsBrigading, Botnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#ElectionWatch: Italy’s Self-Made Bots.
-
Date first seen2014
-
TargetItaly
-
MethodsBrigading, Botnets, Other
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Facebook Removes Iran-based Assets. Again.
-
Date first seen2015
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections, Non-State Political Actor
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Facebook Dismantled Iranian Influence Operation.
-
Date first seen2015
-
TargetWest and Central Africa
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Political Party, Minority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook Disabled Assets Linked to Egypt and UAE-Based Firms.
-
Date first seen2015
-
TargetMiddle East
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Elections, Terrorism, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
IN DEPTH: Iranian Propaganda Network Goes Down.
-
Date first seen2016
-
TargetIndonesia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsInfluential Individual, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook Takes down Iranian Assets, Some Targeting Latin American Audiences.
-
Date first seen2016
-
TargetLatin America
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor, Terrorism, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Royally Removed: Facebook Takes Down Pages Promoting Saudi Interests.
-
Date first seen2017
-
TargetTurkey
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media, Advertisment
Russia’s Full Spectrum Propaganda.
-
Date first seen2017
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsBrigading, Sockpuppets, Botnets
-
TopicsInfluential Individual
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#TrollTracker: Russian Traces in Facebook Takedown
-
Date first seen2017
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Non-State Political Actor, Minority/Majority Group
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Inauthentic Israeli Facebook Assets Target the World.
-
Date first seen2017
-
TargetWest Africa
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Catalonia Twitter Takedown: Inorganic Campaign Pushed Pro-Independence Content.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetSpain
-
MethodsBrigading, Sockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Non-State Political Actor, Influential Individual
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#TrollTracker: Facebook Takes Down Fake Network in Romania.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetRomania
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#InfluenceForSale: Venezuela’s Twitter Propaganda Mill.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetVenezuela
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsSocial Media, Messaging Platforms
#ElectionWatch: Likes from Afar in Oaxaca.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMexico
-
MethodsOther
-
Topics—
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#TrollTracker: Glimpse Into a French Operation.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetFrance
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Minority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#BalticBrief: NATO Not Planning To Invade Belarus.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetLithuania
-
MethodsSockpuppets, Data Exfiltration
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor
-
PlatformsOpen Web
#ElectionWatch: FGV DAPP Uncovers Foreign Twitter Influence in Brazil.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetBrazil
-
MethodsSockpuppets, Botnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#PutinAtWar: WADA Hack Shows Kremlin Full-Spectrum Approach.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsDDoS, Data Exfiltration
-
TopicsNon-State Political Actor, Influential Individual, Immigration, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#ElectionWatch: Protests Reinterpreted Online in Brazil.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetBrazil
-
MethodsBrigading, Data Exfiltration, Other Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#ElectionWatch: Inauthentic Activity Tested Ahead Naming Referendum.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetNorth Macedonia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#ElectionWatch: Post-Electoral Bots in Puebla.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMexico
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#BotSpot: Bots Join Backlash Against Islamophobic Cartoon Contest.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetNetherlands
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#BalticBrief: False Story About Collapsed Mall Doesn’t Hold Up.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetLatvia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsOther
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#ElectionWatch: Italy’s Far Right Attacks Right in Closing Moments.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetItaly
-
MethodsBrigading, Botnets, Other Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Non-State Political Actor
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#BalticBrief: False Claim of Plans for Ethnic Cleansing in Latvia.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetLatvia
-
Methods—
-
TopicsMilitary, Minority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Bot Battlefield at #AMLOFest.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMexico
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections, Immigration
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#BalticBrief: Disinformation Through Mistranslation.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetLithuania
-
MethodsOther Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
TopicsMilitary
-
PlatformsSocial Media
From Telegram to Twitter: Top Puerto Rican Officials Plotted Possible Information Operation.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetPuerto Rico
-
MethodsBrigading, Sockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Armenia Assailed by Deceptive “Fact-Checking” Groups, Part 1: The Players.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetArmenia
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsOther
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
#BotSpot: Bots Target Malaysian Elections.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMalaysia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Coordinated Comments in Macedonia
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMacedonia
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Facebook Removes Assets Connected to Egyptian Newspaper El Fagr.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetEgypt
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMilitary
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
UAE Facebook Pages Targeted Qatar and Muslim Brotherhood.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetMiddle East and North Africa (MENA)
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Non-State Political Actor, Terrorism
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook Takes down Pro-Indonesian Pages Targeting West Papua.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetIndonesia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsMinority/Majority Group, Terrorism, Economic Issues
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Inauthentic Pages Linked to Majority Government Taken down in Georgia.
-
Date first seen2018
-
TargetGeorgia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Twitter's Hong Kong Archives: Chinese Commercial Bots at Work.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetHong Kong
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsInfluential Individual, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Bot-Like Accounts and Pro-Government Hashtags in Colombia.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetColombia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsMilitary, Influential Individual
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Gavrilov’s Night': Multiple Facebook Pages Target Protests in Georgia.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetGeorgia
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Influential Individual, Minority/Majority Group
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Libyan Hashtag Campaign Has Broader Designs: Trolling Qatar.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetLibya
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsMilitary, Political Party, Terrorism
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#ElectionWatch: Bots on Both Sides in India.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetIndia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Elections
-
PlatformsSocial Media
#TrollTracker: Spam Attack on Secretary Pompeo.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetUnited States
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsOther
-
PlatformsSocial Media
How a “Political Astroturfing” App Coordinates Pro-Israel Influence Operations.
-
Date first seen2019
-
Target—
-
MethodsBrigading
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor, Terrorism
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Social Media Spam Tactics in Indonesia.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetIndonesia
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Civilian Militias in Venezuela Coordinate on Twitter.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetVenezuela
-
MethodsBrigading, Botnets
-
TopicsMilitary
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Sockpuppet Accounts Impersonate India’s Space Agency Chief.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetIndia
-
MethodsSockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party, Other
-
PlatformsSocial Media
Secondary Infektion Redux? Suspected Russian Intelligence Operation Targets Greenland.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetGreenland
-
MethodsOther Deceptive Content Manipulation
-
Topics—
-
PlatformsOpen Web, Social Media
Facebook and Twitter Remove Accounts Connected to Spanish Political Party.
-
Date first seen2019
-
TargetSpain
-
MethodsBrigading, Sockpuppets
-
TopicsPolitical Party
-
PlatformsSocial Media, Messaging Platforms
Bot-like Turkish Accounts Complement Military Operation in Syria.
-
Date first seen2019
-
Target—
-
MethodsBotnets
-
TopicsMilitary, Non-State Political Actor, Minority/Majority Group, Terrorism, Immigration
-
PlatformsSocial Media
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
Year Campaign Started
Methodology
This project visualizes the Atlantic Council’s Digital Forensic Research Lab (DFRLab) research on coordinated disinformation campaigns. The project makes it possible to search, compare, and visualize a select group of coordinated disinformation campaigns that have been identified and studied by the DFRLab. These campaigns date to as early as 2010; several are still ongoing.
The DFRLab defines disinformation as “false or misleading information, spread with the intention to deceive.” Political disinformation is defined as “disinformation with a political or politically adjacent end.” The DFRLab defines political disinformation campaigns as “political disinformation that demonstrates both coordination and a discrete objective.”
These campaigns typically include political astroturfing, in which a seemingly grassroots movement is orchestrated from behind the scenes. These campaigns also typically include coordinated inauthentic behavior, in which social media accounts work together while disguising their identities or objectives. Selected cases do not include instances of political misinformation, in which evidence of coordination or intent is absent.
The Data Visualizer is intended to describe the targets, platforms, methods, origins, and intent of individual political disinformation campaigns. Its classification system mirrors the approach that DFRLab researchers use in evaluating new cases. This system consists of 74 binary variables, such as the technical methods or narrative techniques employed, and 24 text descriptors, such as concurrent events or the campaign’s inferred objective. The system offers a high degree of granularity and enables comparison of cases across disparate cultural and political contexts.
Each case is based on existing public documentation of a political disinformation campaign. This approach ensures that case selection is consistent and transparent. However, it will also result in a degree of overlap as more cases are added to the database.
The initial database consists of 60 cases. Each case has been independently coded by two researchers, with disagreements tracked and reconciled in a collaborative process. Initial cases are limited to studies previously published by the DFRLab.
Because less reporting is available on cases that target the Global South and because the total number of cases is potentially inexhaustible, the database should not be used to draw definitive judgments about the prevalence of disinformation in some nations over others.
When assessing cases of disinformation, attribution presents a particular challenge. While disinformation is, by definition, deliberate and carried out with intent, proving both the actor and intent occurs with varying degrees of confidence in every case. The database delineates attribution in cases cited, but also attempts to demonstrate the scale of confidence necessary to make objective assessments that differentiate disinformation from misinformation.
The campaigns included reflect DFRLab's own analysis and perspective, using their own tools and datasets or those obtained from their partners. Google does not endorse these research findings or their characterization of disinformation campaigns. Google combats coordinated disinformation campaigns across its products and its enforcement actions are driven by its own independent investigations, which include consideration of intelligence and data that is not available to external researchers. The Visualizer is intended to help newcomers better understand disinformation campaigns. DFRLab’s research predominantly relies on open source, English language press reporting of coordinated disinformation campaigns that may appear to target the West.
You can view the detailed methodology, codebook, and whitepaper on DFRLab’s GitHub page, here.
Glossary
Methods
Narrative Techniques
Topics